You defined the relationship—but not much else. With the holiday season approaching, you don’t want to scare off your new man with a gift that screams serious commitment, nor should you flippantly throw him a thoughtless bauble and call it a day. Strike the perfect balance with our roundup of boyfriend gifts that show an appropriate amount of how much you care, like elevated sportswear, affordable electronics, and a subtle hint that you’re ready for the next step. Ahead, 50 sweet gifts that remind him the reason he swiped right.